Log in

No account? Create an account
Pirates of the Burley Griffin
A schedule bears the same relationship to reality as Astrology.
Anime Archetypes 
31st-Mar-2010 08:19 pm
Evidently I've wound up doing a panel on Anime Archetypes on Sunday night .This amuses me greatly so I'm going to run with it and try to make it fun for all involved.

What I'd like to get is a list of Anime Archetypes that the audience would like to see discussed.

[Aside: For values of "discussed" that include being trashed by a grumpy old guest who has been becoming increasingly critical of certain archetypes/tropes over the years. But I digress.]

Once I have that list from comments posted here* I'll try to come up with the following for each:

- Do I think it is an archetype (references to TV Tropes may be made)
- The first usage of it that I can recall
- The best usage of it that I can recall 
- Whether or not inclusion is generally a good thing or a bad thing
- Wherther or not inclusion is enough to drive me away on principle

Volunteers to help discuss would also be welcome. :)

*And, yes, that is an utterly shameless** plug for comments.
**What? You thought I wouldn't stoop to that? Bwahahahahahaha. Cough. Splutter.
12th-Mar-2010 08:08 am (UTC)
Thanks for the input.

Noir I'm going to call Girls With Guns rather than Scary Ninja Girl. And, Key? Really?

Not sure what you mean by the Hellsing/Trigun label.

12th-Mar-2010 10:41 am (UTC)
From memory of the Victoria Seras character in Hellsing I'm going to guess that you meant Ms Fanservice.

Which is nice since I wanted an excuse to rant a bit about that one...


Edited at 2010-03-12 10:42 (UTC)
13th-Mar-2010 10:51 am (UTC)
When I did a similar anime archetypes panel a while back I ended up having two versions of the 'girl with gun' archetypes. The older, femme fatale archetypes e.g. Mireille Bouquet from Noir; but also younger girls like the cyborgs from Gunslinger Girl. Even though she doesn't carry a gun, I classified Mikoto Minagi from Mai Hime as a young gun girl.
13th-Mar-2010 10:59 am (UTC)
I was about to invite you to be on the panel when I looked at your journal. :(

I take your point but I would tend to discuss the femme fatale (Mireille) and the schoolgirl (Kirika, Mikoto) as different archetypes that come into play independently of the weaponry archetypes.
13th-Mar-2010 01:27 pm (UTC)
Fair enough. I think the 'schoolgirl' archetype contains many sub archetypes - 'cute', 'demure', 'violent', 'tsundre' etc.
13th-Mar-2010 10:00 pm (UTC)
And I thinking about including a "not-schoolgirl" archetype to comment on how rare it is...and how satisfying it is when done well.
13th-Mar-2010 11:04 am (UTC)
There will, however, be some snarky criticism on the subject of Ms Fanservice in the panel.

I get so tired of that sometimes.
This page was loaded Jul 24th 2019, 12:51 am GMT.